They have been predicted since the 1970's. Egyptian president Sadat, for instance, referred to water scarcity as "the only matter that could take Egypt to war again". From then, indicators on water use and water availability demonstrate that water scarcity has increased - but still these wars didn't happen. More, societies seem to be quite resilient to the effects of water scarcity. So why does this dangerous discourse of potential water wars and water scarcity as a threat to national security still persist?
On this website, I will explore this contradiction in the water politics of the Nile River Basin and in the Middle East. We look into issues that link water and development, and how governance of increasingly scarce water resources relates to conflict over access to and control over these resources. Especially when geopolitics enters the stage, and ideology and 'security' gets in the way of development.
Water, development and conflict
In the Nile River Basin, every aspect of human development is connected by water. Growing food, basic hygiene, earning a living, doing sports or having a nice preserving the natural environment all depend on access to sufficient water. But population growth and economic development push the rapidly rising demand for water; they also lead to environmental degradation and climate change, putting additional pressure on water resources and treatening their renewable supply. Water then becomes increasingly scarce.
Water with borders
When states compete over these scarce water resources, often 'national security' pops up as a concern. Water then gets politicized - 'securitized' - and becomes a devisive rather than a binding element. As national security and ideology are closely linked, it will be increasingly difficult for states to compromise on sharing these water resources.
This is especially the case in the Middle East and the Nile River Basin, and tensions over water gave birth to the discourse of 'water conflicts' and 'rivers of fire', images that popular media are eager to adopt.
On the face of it, violent interstate competition over water resources doesn't seem so strange in the context of ongoing political tensions in the Middle East. Can't water fuel the fire in the Israeli-Arab conflict, or spark something more dangerous among Turkey, Kurds, Saoudi Arabia or Iran in the Big Game of the Gulf?
Past experiences demonstrate that cooperation is however more likely to happen than open conflict over water. Just as every once in a while, tensions rise over damming the Nile River, adversaries still sit together in the conference rooms of the Nile Basin Initiative.
In 2015, the United Nations member states adopted the Sustainable Development Goals, the "17 goals to transform the world" as part of a new development Agenda 2030. Water is an interlinking element in these SDGs: not only where it is mentioned as a Goal as such (clean water, sanitation) but is directly or indirectly linked to every other Goal. This is the case for obvious Goals like climate action or life on land, but also for ending poverty or quality education.